Jewelry that doesn't tarnish is made from stainless steel, gold filled, or solid gold. These materials hold up through water, sweat, and daily wear without losing their finish. Gold-plated jewelry and gold vermeil always fade eventually. That's not a quality issue; it's just how the process works.
If you want a piece you can put on and forget about, the material is the only thing that matters.
How the Main Metals Compare
| Material | What It Is | Durability | Water / Sweat | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Solid Gold | Gold all the way through | ★★★★★ | ★★★★★ | $$$$$ | Lifetime pieces |
| Stainless Steel with PVD | Steel core with a bonded colour finish | ★★★★ | ★★★★★ | $$ | Waterproof daily jewelry |
| Gold Filled | Thick gold layer bonded to a metal core | ★★★★ | ★★★★ | $$$ | Everyday affordable gold |
| Sterling Silver | Silver all the way through | ★★★★ | ★★★★ | $$ | Classic silver pieces |
| Gold Vermeil | Gold over a sterling silver base | ★★★ | ★★★ | $$$ | Occasional wear |
| Gold Plated | Thin gold layer over a base metal | ★★ | ★ | $ | Trend pieces, occasional wear |
Why Jewelry Tarnishes
Tarnishing is a chemical reaction. Metal reacts with moisture, oxygen, sweat, and the products you put on your skin. The surface dulls, gold tones shift toward pale yellow or greenish-grey, and sometimes it leaves marks on your skin.
The materials most likely to tarnish quickly: brass, copper, zinc, mixed alloys, and especially gold-plated pieces where the protective layer wears through with time.
Materials That Hold Up
Stainless steel in silver finish
The most durable option for everyday wear. Stainless steel doesn't react to water, sweat, or skincare products. You can wear it in the shower, at the beach, at the gym. It stays looking the same. It's also nickel-free, which significantly reduces the risk of skin irritation and allergic reactions.
Stainless steel with PVD coating in gold and rose gold finish
PVD (Physical Vapor Deposition) is an industrial process that bonds color directly into the metal surface rather than depositing it on top like regular plating. The gold or rose gold finish created by PVD holds up for years with daily wear, resists water and sweat, and doesn't peel or flake. It's not gold, but it's not plating either. It's the most durable option for a gold look without the upkeep that real gold requires. Like the base stainless steel, it's nickel-free.
gold filled
Gold filled is a legally regulated product. The gold layer must make up at least 1/20th of the item's total weight (stamped "1/20 GF") and is mechanically bonded to a base metal core using heat and pressure, not electroplating. Chlorine, saltwater, and friction at contact points (clasps, chain links) are the main factors that accelerate wear.
solid gold
The one that simply never tarnishes. Gold is naturally inert. It doesn't react to moisture or air. A solid gold piece can be worn for a lifetime without losing its finish. That's why it's the standard for high-end permanent jewelry.
Sterling silver
Sterling silver (925) can tarnish slightly over time, especially when exposed to air. But it cleans up easily and gets its shine back in a few minutes. For a permanent sterling silver piece, it's a durable option as long as you give it occasional care.
Gold-Plated and Vermeil: Why They Fade
Both gold plating and gold vermeil work the same way: a layer of gold is deposited over a base metal. The difference is thickness. Vermeil is thicker than basic plate, but it's still a coating sitting on top of another metal.
With daily friction, water, and cosmetic products, that coating wears through. It's not a sign of bad craftsmanship. It's physics. If you're searching for gold vermeil jewelry because you want something that holds up long-term, the honest answer is: stainless steel with PVD coating or gold filled will last significantly longer for daily wear.
For a piece you wear occasionally, vermeil is fine. For something that stays on through your whole day, PVD or gold filled is the better call.
What Prysm Carries
All of Prysm's everyday jewelry is made from stainless steel, nickel-free. Waterproof, hypoallergenic, designed to be worn without taking off. Gold and rose gold finishes use PVD coating. No plating, no coating that fades. Necklaces, bracelets, earrings: wear them through your shower, your workout, your whole week.
For permanent jewelry, we work with three materials: gold filled, sterling silver 925, and solid gold. The chain is custom-fitted and welded during your appointment at our studio on Plateau-Mont-Royal in Montreal. No clasp, no upkeep. Just a piece that stays.
Shop everyday jewelry
Book a permanent jewelry appointment
Frequently Asked Questions
Does stainless steel leave green marks on skin?
No. Green marks come from copper or brass in low-quality jewelry. Quality stainless steel doesn't cause that reaction.
Is stainless steel nickel-free?
Yes, at Prysm. The stainless steel we use is nickel-free, making it suitable for sensitive skin and anyone who typically reacts to jewelry.
What's the difference between PVD coating and gold plating?
Gold plating deposits a thin layer of gold through a chemical process. PVD bonds the color into the metal surface through a physical process in a vacuum chamber. The result is much harder, more scratch-resistant, and far more durable through water and daily wear.
What's the difference between gold filled and gold plated?
Gold filled has a layer of gold that's roughly 100 times thicker than standard plating, bonded to the base metal rather than just deposited on top. It lasts much longer and won't flake under normal wear.
Does permanent jewelry tarnish?
Depends on the material. Solid gold: never. Gold filled: barely, over several years. Sterling silver: slightly with time, easy to maintain.